Nextcloud vs Samba: folder sharing for usage by external devices

I have no support/technical question and have seen the support category. (Be aware that direct support questions will be deleted.)

on

Which general topic do you have

Hello,

my hifi device can access folders shared by Windows / SAMBA and play music files from there. I tried to connect to a folder shared by Nexcloud, but it would not connect. A webdav share does not seen to be within my hifi’s capabilities.

Is there any way of making this work, though? I guess NC can not be made disguising itself as a SAMBA server when sharing a folder, can it?

The next best idea that comes to my mind would be installing SAMBA, creating a share and letting NC mount / use this share as a “remote” storage. Since it’s on the same physical machine, this diversion should not cause any great performance issue.

Wold this be a solution to my problem? Or is there some other solution to achieve the desired, I am not aware of?

Thanks in advance for any hints and advices!

Hello @weka,

contrary to your confirmation, you have submitted a support request in this category.

Fill out the support template as completely as possible.

If your HiFi device is compatible with either Ampache or Subsonic, you should use the music app:

App-Id music
App-Name Music
Summary Music player, library viewer, and server
App can not be restricted to groups
Categories multimedia
Repository GitHub - owncloud/music: 🎶 Music app for ownCloud
Issue-Tracker GitHub · Where software is built
Not-shipped (not included) App available in appstore
Appstore https://apps.nextcloud.com/apps/music

it makes your cloud a music server for external devices.

h.t.h.


ernolf

1 Like

I’m sorry, but in my post I was not asking for help with a specific app, a program or some configuration. It was a general question meant to gather ideas of how I could achieve the goal. I did not regard these questions as a support request.

What’s interesting about your post is that you felt it was more important to justify yourself than to respond to the post, which actually made a suggestion on how you could achieve an even better solution than the one you have now. :wink:

If you want to stick with SAMBA shares, or have to because your receiver doesn’t support Ampache or Subsonic, then I would leave the SAMBA shares as they are and leave Nextcloud out of it. You can still make the existing SAMBA shares available to Nextcloud via Nextcloud’s External Storage app.

And no, Nextcloud cannot serve files via SAMBA; it can only do so via HTTP/WebDAV. Also, files managed by Nextcloud should not be accessed in any other way, and I would not recommend sharing the Nextcloud data folder or parts of it via SAMBA.

Follow @ernolf’s suggestion or, if that is not possible, keep the existing SAMBA share. If its content is also to be used in Nextcloud, you can add it via the External Storage app: Configuring External Storage (GUI) — Nextcloud latest Administration Manual latest documentation

Hope that helps.

3 Likes