I don’t get the link from “it is to complicated” to the request of adding a poll where everybody can change all votes.
Sorry for the following off topic part
This is not off topic. This is requested feedback.
Since a couple of years i try to “catch them” by supporting the Polls App. But the main reason for rejection is “it doesn’t look & feel like doodle”
If a user says it is to complicated, I am really interested in some more specific feedback. This helps to improve the UX more and more. The design (Does not look sexy) is bound to the nextcloud style guide.
Comparing to Doodle
Using Doodle as a participant, you directly get to the vote page and have to enter your name as the first action.
In polls, you first have to register with your name and then you get to the votepage. So ther is no real difference from my point of view.
What is the reason for the register modal?
- Some users of polls want to get the email address (mandatory or optional) of the participants.
- Also another request is to be able to login, if you take part in a public poll but want to participate as the site user who has a login
This is the reason, we present the registration modal first. But you have to provide the same information as doodle requests; just a name.
The other point is, that doodle permits any user to change every vote. This is not possible in polls, because the concept bases upon the decision, that every user is only allowed to change his own votes.
Breaking this principle has a huge impact on the current architecture. It is expensive compared to a limited value.
Polls is not directly supported or developed by Nextcloud although the repository is located with the nextcloud namespace. Currently I am the only maintainer and my time gets limited more and more, ATM. The originally maintainer is also limited with his time, so he is just able to maintain the releases in his spare free time.
This is the downside of OS, if you are dependent on some enthusiast, who develop as a hobby.
BUT: Polls is open source. Any other enthusiast is welcome to support the deveopment or even fork the repository and enhance the app at his own mind.
Anyways thanks for your efforts to support the usage of this app. I really appreciate this. But I hope you understand my point.
And: If you really try to promote Polls since years, I hope you can confirm a huge improvement over the years. Just for my own soul