Files Access Control - issue with browsing folders

Hello,

when i restricted access on folder this way

Files Access Control:
File collaborative tag - is tagged with - GroupTag
User group membership - is not member of group - Group

and added Collaborative tag GroupTag to this folder, user who is not a member of any group can browse all files/folders in this folder and in all its subfolders. User is not allowed to access files contained in this folder.
How can I prevent this file browsing?

Thanks

This is intended for now, also see https://docs.nextcloud.com/server/10/admin_manual/configuration_files/files_access_control.html#denied-access

Trying to remove name iteration is way to error prone, so nothing we can garantee. Therefor we don’t support it at all.

Edited Post:

I have made some tests and i’ve found something strange:

Case A:
Files Access Control:
File collaborative tag - is tagged with - ACCES_DENIED
User group membership - is not member of group - GROUP_A

User management
User is member of group GROUP_A

Tag Folder
Folder is tagged with ACCES_DENIED

Result
User see the content in the folder but he cannot upload or open anything.

Case B:
Files Access Control:
File collaborative tag - is tagged with - ACCES_DENIED
User group membership - is member of group - GROUP_B

User management
User is member of group GROUP_B

Tag Folder
Folder is tagged with ACCESS_DENIED

RESULT
User don’t see the content ! (that’s we need) and can’t upload, perfect !


As you can see, we don’t have the same behavior if we change “is member of group” and “is not member of group”. Is it a bug?

Can you see if https://github.com/nextcloud/server/pull/1771/files fixes the issue for you?
Make sure to delete the correct line, as the code it there twice.

Hi :slight_smile:

I have deleted the line mentioned in https://github.com/nextcloud/server/pull/1771/files
in manager.php, but the user still can view the content of the denied folder.