I have at the moment Linux Ubuntu with a nextcloud 20 working on a Intel NUC i3 (3 Ghz) and it works like a charm. I need a second Nextcloud server that will need access by 3 users only. I was wondering if a celeron NUC (1,5 Ghz) would be plenty enough!!! What are your experience?
It depends on the model. Some have installed it on a Raspberry 3B+ which might work, but don’t expect a good performance. A Raspberry 4 performs much better, especially with 2 or 4 GB RAM
The NextcloudPi Image seem to be well optimized for this device
You should also consider an external USB drive. Much faster and you can also move the DB to that to reduce write attempts to the SDCard. But this can be managed also very easy with the NCP image.
I’m currently using a Pi 4 4GB setup with a NCP image.
I have 7 users and lots of apps, it’s really on the limit, and I’m thinking of buying a second hand NUC. But I find it very difficult to compare it to my current setup.
I could buy a NUC6CAYS for cheap, but I wonder if it would be any better or only use 4x as much electricity and bring no improvement in speed.
I’d recommend this model:
And BTW: the TDP is the max. power consumption. in reality (e.g. idle) the power consumption of NUC’s is much less then the TDP: I see around 6W in idle with an internal SSD (It is around the same for more powerful NUC’s, too).
Not really a comparison. Neither from performance nor from price.
The documented HPE ProLiant Micro Server with 8 GB RAM starts at $450, you can get 10 Pi4 for it.
They attract with a Windows license (Desktop, not Server). But there is no need running Nextcloud on Windows.
Whatever I run on RPi - Kodi, Asterisk, Wordpress, Nextcloud - was always suffering from power supply instabilities. By the time you remedy this - good adapters, UPS - the savings from not using something better are gone…
If you do price comparsions, you have to do them right…
Not only more dificult, but also more expensive. While you might not need a seperate case for each Raspi, you definitvely need some case and a PSU for each Raspi. In addition to that you need a switch and patch cables. Maybe with a cluster of five you can match the price of the HP-Server. Ok and then you have a cluster with more cores and more RAM in total, of which an application like nextcloud can derive little to no advantage, because the compute power and the RAM is clustered over multiple nodes.
Same thing if you compare single board computers with NUCs. A Celeron NUC is not necessary that much more expensive. An 8GB Raspi4 with a case, PSU and storage can can easy hit the 200$ mark. And the x86 Celeron single board computers (OrDroid and others) are definitely not worth it, compared to a NUC with Celeron and imho also not compared to an i3 NUC, if you don’t just look strictly at the price.
And what most of the single board computer fans seem to forget is, that not everybody wants to thinker with things. A NUC always comes with a case, a suitable cooling solution and a PSU. The RAM is socketed and therefore expandable. A NVME and a 2.5 ‘’ disk can be installed directly inside the case and do not have to be plugged in via USB and somehow glued into a 3D-printed plastic case together with the board.